gmail loosing unread mail status in threaded mails ?
Saturday, February 10th, 2007I have been using gmail for a while now, and am mostly satisfied with it. The threaded system it is based on has some good points and bad points, but so far nothing that required me to reconsider changing my setup. Things have changed.
I missed an important mail part of a ongoing thread on Thursday. The person who wrote me that mail resent me a mail on Friday. That mail ended up in the same ‘conversation’. When I read that second mail I discovered the previous mail, strangely marked with a read status. I am pretty sure I didn’t read that mail. I am sure I didn’t see that conversation marked as read in my Inbox. I am sure I didn’t click on update this conversation and read that mail afterwards.
Now this is at least the second time this happens to me in the past 2 months. First time, the mail wasn’t that important and I assumed an user error. Now this time I have big doubts.
Could there be a bug in gmail’s mail read status in connection to threaded conversations. Maybe some kind of
timing issue ? Or something that gets the mail marked as read even if it wasn’t displayed properly ?
I doubt it, but nevertheless, twice the same problem in a short period while I’ve never had a problem in years is strange.
Note: around the same time I received that mail, I was in a network that had failures due to(?) a mis-configured WebWasher proxy. That’s too important to leave this out. In particular that proxy caused errors with gmail. E.g. I couldn’t read my mail properly and couldn’t logout. More info below. I wonder if the issue could come from a combination of proxy error and bad update. So could this 2 problems be linked ? Could there be a code path in the gmail Ajax calls that update the mailbox statuses that don’t properly handle failures ?
This type of problem is not new in the world of “web 2.0″ applications. I stopped using BlogLines because they also used to have errors with their read status count. I noticed that google Reader (beta) starts having similar failures (some of them perhaps related to the fact that sometimes my google reader page is opened on multiple PCs ?), and now gmail…
I haven’t contacted Google yet. I still believe it could be a user error. But I will watch out for the third time…
Webwasher failures

I contacted the vendor on Thursday, let’s see if they answer…
For info, the version of Webwasher was 6.0.1 Build 2533